User:Appeal background

Sorry the situation is a bit complicated but you need this information to advise us. Short summary: Since the appeal was at AE then in principle ArbCom can override them. My friend thinks that they have good reason to appeal on the basis that the admins who imposed these additional sanctions didn’t seem to realize they were covered by TBANEX during the appeal, so, on a procedural irregularity. However as far as we can see, there is no set procedure in place to ask ArbCom to lift sanctions that were improperly imposed during a topic ban appeal in AE. We can’t ask ArbCom because they said they will not reply except to an email that includes the appeal itself.
 * My friend (not me) has a topic ban, an indef block and a one-way i-ban.
 * The t-ban was imposed for things they can prove they didn’t do. But the admins are not interested in looking at their evidence that they didn’t do these things
 * They were unblocked for six months from December 2017 through to June 2018 during which they made many contributions to wikipedia outside the topic ban area.
 * They then appealed to AE at the proper time and during the appeal should have been covered by TBANEX. The admins didn’t say anything to override this. During this appeal they presented evidence (as they have before on previous appeals) that they didn’t do the things another editor accuses them of doing
 * During the appeal they were given a one month block and an unusual one-way i-ban against this editor.
 * They never interacted with the editor they have an i-ban against during the six months leading up to the appeal. All they have ever done between previous aappeals is to tell him to go away and delete his comments on their talk page - he has tried to post to their talk page four times.
 * During the appeal they referred to the accusations made by this other editor during a legitimate appeal process.
 * They were not told that any additional requirements were in place that meant that this risked an i-ban.
 * They have been told they can’t appeal the i-ban until after the next t-ban appeal, which would be at least a year after a successful unblock.
 * While expressing concerns about the i-ban during a short conversation after the failed appeal the block was extended to an indef block.
 * 2 weeks after their failed appeal this other editor pinged them in their topic banned area, knowing that they were also indef blocked and under a one-way i-ban saying something about them they could be expected to object to.